Is It Compatibility or Chemistry? What Actually Makes a Marriage Work

In India, we have two main scripts for marriage.

Script A (The Bollywood Romance): You meet someone. Your eyes lock. You feel electricity. You fight the world to be together. The movie ends at the wedding. Script B (The Practical Arrangement): Your parents find a “suitable” match. Same caste, same salary bracket, same diet. You meet once. You get married.

So, which one works? The answer is usually: Neither.

Marriages fail when people confuse Chemistry with Compatibility. They think the “spark” is enough to pay the bills (it isn’t). Or they think “matching biodatas” is enough to create intimacy (it isn’t).

As a Clinical Psychologist, I see couples in my office 10 years after the wedding. I can tell you exactly what keeps them together. It is not the electricity. It is the architecture.

The Trap of Chemistry (The “Spark”)

Chemistry is biological. It is Dopamine and Testosterone. It is that feeling of “I can’t eat, I can’t sleep, I need to see them.” It is addictive. It is beautiful. But it is a trick.

The Science of the “Honeymoon Phase”: Evolution designed this “spark” to last exactly 12 to 18 months. That is just enough time to meet, mate, and bond. After that, your brain stops producing those high-intensity chemicals. The fog clears. Suddenly, you realize they chew loudly. You realize they are bad with money. You realize they never listen.

If your entire relationship was built on the Spark, the relationship dies when the Spark dies. Chemistry is the match that starts the fire. But matches burn out in seconds.

The Power of Compatibility (The “Wood”)

Compatibility is not sexy. It is boring. It is about values, lifestyle, and how you handle a crisis. Compatibility is the wood that keeps the fire burning for 50 years.

It is not about liking the same pizza toppings. It is about answering three hard questions:

1. Do we fight fair? (Conflict Style)
2. Do we view money the same way? (Financial Values)
3. Do we want the same life? (Shared Vision)

The 3 Pillars of a “Working” Marriage

If you are deciding between two people, or trying to fix your current marriage, stop looking for butterflies. Look for these three pillars.

1. The “Roommate Test” (Lifestyle)

Forget the romance. Can you live with this person as a roommate?

• Are you a morning person and they are a night owl?
• Do you like a spotless house while they leave wet towels on the bed? These small “annoyances” become huge resentments over 20 years. Compatibility means your daily rhythms flow together without constant friction.

2. The “Wallet War” (Financial Values)

In India, this is the #1 cause of divorce. One partner wants to save every rupee for a house. The other wants to travel to Europe on EMI. Neither is “wrong.” But they are incompatible. You need a partner whose financial anxiety matches yours.

3. The “In-Law” Boundary

How much influence will the parents have?

• Partner A thinks: “My parents will visit every weekend.”
• Partner B thinks: “We will see them on festivals.” If you don’t align on this, your marriage will become a battleground of loyalties.

Can You Build Chemistry? (The Arranged Marriage Advantage)

This is the good news for the “Script B” couples. Chemistry can be grown. It is called “The Slow Burn.” When you have high compatibility (safety, trust, respect), intimacy often grows deeper over time because you feel safe with the person. You aren’t worried they will ghost you. You can relax. And relaxation is the best aphrodisiac.

Can You Build Compatibility? (The Love Marriage Challenge) This is harder. It is very difficult to change someone’s core values. You cannot teach a spender to be a saver easily. You cannot teach a chaotic person to be organized without them resenting you. If you have high chemistry but zero compatibility, you will have a passionate, disastrous relationship. It will be a rollercoaster—fun highs, terrible lows.

The Final Verdict

The “Gold Standard” Marriage has High Compatibility + Medium Chemistry. You need enough spark to want to hold hands, but enough compatibility to pay the mortgage without killing each other.

Don’t Guess, Assess.

• For the “Confused” Single: If you are torn between two people or unsure about a Rishta, don’t trust your gut. Your gut is drunk on dopamine. Trust a professional assessment. Find a Relationship Expert for Clarity
• For the “Roommates” (Married but Bored): If the chemistry is dead but the compatibility is good, you can reignite the spark. But if you are lonely, start by talking to someone safe. Talk to a Relationship Coach on VentOut
• Check Your Relationship Health: Are you compatible or just codependent? Take the test. Take the Compatibility Test

Final Thought

Don’t look for a Prince Charming or a Dream Girl. Look for a partner who fights fair, respects your dreams, and makes the boring Tuesday nights feel peaceful. That is the only happily ever after that exists.

---

📚 References & Further Reading

1. Gottman, J. – The Science of Trust: Emotional Attunement for Couples.
2. Fisher, Helen – Anatomy of Love: A Natural History of Mating, Marriage, and Why We Stray.
3. Sternberg, R. J. – The Triangular Theory of Love.